American Express logo Discover logo Mastercard logo Paypal logo Visa logo
Lifetime Warranty, 100% Diamond Trade-Up, & Free Shipping on All Orders. Learn More close
Our Diamonds

Our Diamonds

We carry only GIA-certified gemstones, including ethically sourced Canadian mined diamonds and lab-cultivated diamonds, and Charles & Colvard moissanites.

SHOP RINGS

Discover evertrue


Discover the everture collection - our exclusive line of lab-cultiavted, real GIA-certified diamonds. An evertrue diamond is the socially-responsible, fairly priced option for discerning diamond shoppers.

learn more
Discover evertrue

Shop New Arrivals


  • 1.00 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (GM04361S) 1.00 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (GM04361S)
  • 1.00 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (GM04428S) 1.00 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (GM04428S)
  • 1.07 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Lab-Cultivated Diamond - signature evertrue (GM04303S) 1.07 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Lab-Cultivated Diamond - signature evertrue (GM04303S)
  • 1.10 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Lab-Cultivated Diamond - select evertrue (GM04305S) 1.10 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Lab-Cultivated Diamond - select evertrue (GM04305S)
  • 3.28 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (TA5878S) 3.28 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (TA5878S)
  • 3.00 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (GMXXRD300S)
  • 2.57 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (GM03778S) 2.57 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (GM03778S)
  • 3.15 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (TA9149S) 3.15 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (TA9149S)
  • 2.40 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (TA5679S) 2.40 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (TA5679S)
  • 2.50 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (GMXXRD250S)
  • 2.13 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (AF713S) 2.13 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (AF713S)
  • 2.25 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (GMXXRD225S)
  • 2.37 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (AF1458S) 2.37 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (AF1458S)
  • 1.83 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (GM03981S) 1.83 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (GM03981S)
  • 2.01 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (GM03045S) 2.01 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (GM03045S)
  • 2.03 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (TA5259S) 2.03 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (TA5259S)
  • 2.00 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - select ICING (GMXXRD200S)
  • 1.76 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (TA9206S) 1.76 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (TA9206S)
  • 1.68 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (TA5761S) 1.68 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - signature ICING (TA5761S)
  • 1.51 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (TA5758S) 1.51 Ct. Round GIA-Certified Diamond - premium ICING (TA5758S)
Loading
Create a Custom Design

Diamonds You Can Trust


All Icing On The Ring mined and lab diamonds have been graded by the Gemological Institute of America. Certified diamonds allow you to compare one diamond of a particular weight and grade with other diamonds of similar weight and grade. The report is your assurance that the diamond is independently recognized as possessing all the measurable, quantifiable aspects of the 4 C's.

Learn More

Follow Along on Instagram

@icingonthering