Icing On The Ring

Your jewelry is a reflection of your personality and taste. Although Icing On The Ring offers a wide selection of styles to choose from, you might be envisioning a piece unique to your aesthetic preferences. Have a design in mind? Share a drawing or picture with us, and we'll work together to create the ring of your dreams. With over 40 years of expertise, Icing On The Ring is ready to help create your custom piece, without the "custom" price tag.

people being consulted about jewelry
 delivery icon

Expedited Order Service

The majority of Icing On The Ring products featured on our site are made to order and produced within your established timeline. We prefer to tailor each ring personally - to match finger size and incorporate your personal choice of precious metal and center gem proportions. Our on premise production studio provides us with the ability to produce your piece within a two-week time frame. If your special day is coming up fast, we will gladly expedite the production of your order at no extra cost.

 delivery icon


Icing On The Ring aims to fit into your fiscal plan while offering choice and support along the way. We offer three flexible financing options - deferred interest, or long-term or revolving credit plans.

Learn more about Icing On The Ring's financing options.

IOTR Financing
a jewelry craftsman making a diamond ring


Icing On The Ring offers complimentary appraisals upon request, should you want to insure your jewelry purchase. The appraised value will represent the retail replacement cost of your jewelry, sufficient to cover you should you need to file a loss or damage claim with your insurance company. For jewelry not purchased from Icing On The Ring, we offer appraisal services for $55 per item.

a jewelry crefstman making a diamond ring
diamond ring


We offer unlimited resizing free of charge within the first year of purchase, so long as the adjustment is within one full size (up or down). Some gentlemen’s and ladies wedding bands do not fall under this policy, especially those that have diamonds spanning all the way around. The jewelry work may take up to two weeks to complete. ***

***Eternity wedding bands are subject to additional fees.
a jewelry craftsman making a diamond ring
 delivery icon

Jewelry Insurance

You've found the perfect ring. Now, you want it protected.

Icing On The Ring suggests insuring your ring through Jewelers Mutual or Gemsafe Insurance.This added protection ensures that your prized possession is covered against loss, theft, and incidental damages.

 delivery icon

Sell Your Jewelry

Give your unwanted, outdated jewelry a second life. Hand them over to Icing On The Ring for competitive cash offers or redeem 15% more in-store credit over our cash offer! We'll take everything, from broken pieces to scrap gold and loose diamonds. Of course, all transactions are private and confidential.

If you accept our offer for purchase, you can walk out of the store with a check in hand!

How to Sell Your Jewelry

We have dedicated jewelry buyers on premise and ready to help, but we suggest calling or making an appointment Monday through Saturday, to ensure that we're prepared for your visit. During your visit, our jewelry buyer will carefully examine your items to determine the quality and condition of your pieces(s). There are many factors which impact value, but we assess:

  • Metal content (14k vs 18k gold vs platinum for example)
  • Total weight of the metal
  • Gems, such as diamonds
  • Quality of the materials