Proposal Rings

Proposal Rings

For years, popping the question meant making a choice. Do you let your special someone doom a ring at ihe jewelry store and ruin the surprise? Or do you maintain the romance of a spontaneous proposal, and risk chooing an engagement ring they won't love?

Get Started

Preparing You For the Perfect Proposal

We’ve been helping people pop the question for nearly half a century. A lot has changed since 1969, but the concerns customers have about their proposals are always the same:

I don’t know what style she’ll like…
I don’t know her ring size
I think she’ll want to choose her
own ring, but I still want to
surprise her…
I’m afraid of buying
her something she won’t love...

Icing On The Ring has the solution.
We call it a Proposal Ring.

Proposal rings are temporary solitaire settings available with the purchase of a loose center diamond. These 14K gold settings come are at an accessible price point, and enable you to propose with a symbol of your love in hand. After you get a yes, trade in the temporary setting at full value for a new, permanent setting of her choice.

Get Started

How It Works

From choosing a diamond to trading in your Proposal Ring at full value, we've made the engagement ring buying process simple.


Pick a Diamond

Purchase a loose center diamond


Choose Your Proposal Ring

Select white, yellow, or rose gold and we'll mount your diamond while you wait


Pop the Question!



Choose a New Setting

Bring your fiancée to our store within 60 days of your initial purchase to pick out or design a new setting


Ordering Online?

Contact us after the proposal to arrange the trade-in for your new setting. We’ll provide you with everything you need to return the Proposal Ring, and we’ll ship back your newly completed ring free of charge.

Shop Diamonds

Don’t worry…every Icing On The Ring setting includes a lifetime warranty against imperfections in design and craftsmanship.

Learn More

Make Your Proposal Perfect

Contact Icing On The Ring to get started with your diamond proposal ring.

Walk-ins are welcome, but we do encourage appointments. Schedule one online here or call us at:

(888) 565-6150


Weekdays: 10am-6pm

Saturday: 10am-5pm

Sunday: Closed