American Express logo Discover logo Mastercard logo Paypal logo Visa logo
Lifetime Warranty, 100% Diamond Trade-Up, & Free Shipping on All Orders. Learn More close
Proposal Rings
white_ring

Proposal Rings

For years, popping the question meant making a choice. Do you let your special someone doom a ring at ihe jewelry store and ruin the surprise? Or do you maintain the romance of a spontaneous proposal, and risk chooing an engagement ring they won't love?

Get Started

Preparing You For the Perfect Proposal

We’ve been helping people pop the question for nearly half a century. A lot has changed since 1969, but the concerns customers have about their proposals are always the same:

PreparingProposalChat_banner
I don’t know what style she’ll like…
I don’t know her ring size
I think she’ll want to choose her
own ring, but I still want to
surprise her…
I’m afraid of buying
her something she won’t love...
ProposalRing

Icing On The Ring has the solution.
We call it a Proposal Ring.

Proposal rings are temporary solitaire settings available with the purchase of a loose center diamond. These 14K gold settings come are at an accessible price point, and enable you to propose with a symbol of your love in hand. After you get a yes, trade in the temporary setting at full value for a new, permanent setting of her choice.

Get Started

How It Works

From choosing a diamond to trading in your Proposal Ring at full value, we've made the engagement ring buying process simple.

pick_diamond
1

Pick a Diamond

Purchase a loose center diamond

choose_proposal_ring
2

Choose Your Proposal Ring

Select white, yellow, or rose gold and we'll mount your diamond while you wait

pop_question
3

Pop the Question!

 

choose_new_setting
4

Choose a New Setting

Bring your fiancée to our store within 60 days of your initial purchase to pick out or design a new setting

manage_your_account_online

Ordering Online?

Contact us after the proposal to arrange the trade-in for your new setting. We’ll provide you with everything you need to return the Proposal Ring, and we’ll ship back your newly completed ring free of charge.

Shop Diamonds
design_craftsmanship
diamond

Don’t worry…every Icing On The Ring setting includes a lifetime warranty against imperfections in design and craftsmanship.

Learn More

Make Your Proposal Perfect

Contact Icing On The Ring to get started with your diamond proposal ring.

Walk-ins are welcome, but we do encourage appointments. Schedule one online here or call us at:

(888) 565-6150

HOURS

Weekdays: 10am-6pm

Saturday: 10am-5pm

Sunday: Closed